Glenrothes 1998 vintage

Good to know that you are enjoying Glenrothes 1998 - wish I had been gifted my bottle. I find this to be very ordinary whisky.

It is ordinary, but it is not bad. Sometimes a complex dram is what is needed, but in my opinion it is better to have a less complex palate if you have enjoyable flavors.

I find Macallan 12 to be quite the let down, but aberlour 10 is better in my opinion, each person has what they enjoy.

I too was initially disappointed with Macallan 12, but I do enjoy it: I was perhaps expecting too much, as I may have from the Glenrothes 1998. The GlenR 1998 is 'on the shelf' next to Cardhu and Jura Superstition. For a simple dram I go to Macallan CS...currently having a Corryvreckan, that's a long ways off from simple.

i am having me some aberlour 10 or johhnie walker green tonight, both are good but each one is different.

might write a review of green label later on

L12 107 18:46 6ML

Paddock what was that