Kilchoman Machir Bay bottled 2014
Beauty Before Age
4 187
Review by @RianC
- Nose~
- Taste~
- Finish~
- Balance~
- Overall87
Show rating data charts
Distribution of ratings for this:
My first purchase of a Kilchoman having tried a few samples at a festival last year. As I'm sure you all know, Kilchoman is Islay's farm distillery and does everything on-site (I believe). Fair play! This bottle is just less than half full and been open almost three months. I'm having it neat.
Nose: Under ripe banana, anise, a hint of stable, brine, gammon, lemon and lime rind, eucalyptus, ash smoke and some medicinal notes (winter green)
Taste: Lemon rind upfront, sour then the fruity banana comes out. The peat comes in as it develops with ash and aniseed rock sticks. A little creamy vanilla. Slight waxy mouthfeel.
Finish: Smoke and ash, pleasantly bitter tannins. Medium - long
Overall: This is very good but it's worth noting that it has improved lots over the few months it's been open. I feel like the young age of this (4 - 7 years at a guess?) stops it from developing complexity - the flavours are quite bold; but I think this style of whisky can sometimes be better for it, if you like your peat! Not one I'll be rushing to buy again but I can't wait for a 10 - 12 year old release; I think it will be a star when it comes of age.
Find where to buy Kilchoman whisky
This was my first Kilchoman too and I can’t disagree with anything you say, except I would, and did buy it again. I have also had the 100% Islay and I’m anxious to try the highly touted Loch Gorm. Thanks for the very thorough review.