Whisky Connosr
Menu
Buy Whisky Online

Johnnie Walker Blue Label

Is it worth it?

0 270

@bbb63Review by @bbb63

18th Jun 2011

0

Johnnie Walker Blue Label
  • Nose
    18
  • Taste
    15
  • Finish
    14
  • Balance
    23
  • Overall
    70

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

I have had the JW Blue a few times before including the very week it first appeared on American shores where I "traded" an Opus X for a double shot of the just arrived Blue Label at the local high end tavern. I am reviewing this both uncut/neat and will add a few comments when splashed with some water.

The color hue is slightly darker than most JW blends but still gold.

Aroma: The nose first detects a mild peaty smoke and vanilla barrel along with heather, wild flowers, honey, walnuts, cotton candy and an earthy mineral quality. If you open the nose more with some water you can find a hint of Turkish pipe tobacco, leather and raw cacao but risk the loss of the fine mild charred barrel and peat.

Taste: Starts with a smooth mild peat, earthy wood, sea salt, herbal and honey character. Some nutty and marzipan tones are noticed but faint. A light sour apple and allspice tone adds to the profile. The thing is that JW Blue really lacks the forceful roundness and complexity found is single malts, no master blender skill can add what is not there in the spirits. Adding a touch of water really does little but to water down the already mild palate.

Finish: Short on flavors but long on warming when uncut. A tad minerally and tannic dry. Annoying smooth and forgettable when cut with H20.

Mouth feel: Smooth, very balanced and comfortable, like an old pair of shoes.

Overall: Served neat this is a quality dram that you can enjoy with a fine cigar or steak, but simply is a tad short on overall complexity. When (or if) you make the mistake of adding anything beyond just a few DROPS of water you may as well be drink a less expensive whisky, you ruined it. I took one for the team and this review. Final verdict... not worth what you payed for it.

Related Johnnie Walker reviews

2 comments

@mattberg
mattberg commented

I bought a bottle of this in 2008 coming from Brazil back to London and it cost me $70 compared to £170 in the UK. Is it worth it? good question... I kind of felt that something was missing as it never left me feeling satisfied, although a great blend, now I look back and think great marketing...... I'm grateful for finding this whisky as it opened doors to the world of single malts I enjoy today but I doubt if I would buy a bottle again now I've discovered the fabulous mortlach single malt which is the base for JWBL.... hope you can find this where you are.

13 years ago 0

Peatpete commented

I realy enjoy this drop, but worth what you pay... I tend to look at it in the context of "what else could I buy for the same money' (incidentaly this is the thought process that made me abandon persuing membership of the SMWS in Australia). Blue label is gorgeous, but for the $170 - $220 that is costs normaly, I can buy 2 - 3 realy good single malts that I haven't already tried. Looked at from that point of view, I am unlikely to throw my dollars at another bottle of it.

13 years ago 0