Nelom started a discussion
7 years ago
Discussions
1 26
7 years ago
Use the filters above to search this discussion.
@jeanluc That's my impression. From photo looks quite elegant. I would be interested in trying various spirits in it.
But I have to admit my respect for the humble snifter, which really impressed me over the last weekend.
7 years ago 0
@jeanluc Exactly. Which is the same way I've heard the Canadian Glencairn be described. Or Glencairn Mixer Glass as the folks at Glencairn Crystal have started referring to it.
What I like about that glass is that it has some heft to it and that it's eliminated any risk of tipping. This Libbey glass looks like it might also have a bit of weight to it, at least if it has similar proportions to the Canadian Glencairn.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Nelom I just ordered a couple so I hope to be able to report back when they arrive...
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Nozinan What is the humble sniffer you are refering to. Personnaly, I like the Glencairn, but if I don't have enough for a tasting, I find that INAO wine glasses are giving me very good results, usually with more highnotes.
I am also curious to get the opinion of those who tried the SMWS Copita glass. I would like to get a couples but the SMWS is not present in La Belle Province.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Robert99
The humble snifter is an unremarkable brandy snifter a set of which my wife picked up many years ago when I tried a couple of cognacs, well-before my official whisky journey began. It's pretty small, easy to hold and I did one head to head nosing during the epic tasting and found it superior.
I still like Glencairns for durability and overall effectiveness, but I think for tasting notes a snifter may be better.
7 years ago 0
I don't like it. Personally I prefer a more slender, delicate glass. Long stemmed. This fattened glencairn looks more like a way to make some dollar with the industry teaming up with a maker and branding it "official"
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan Please do. I saw they were on sale via the Bourbon trail website but assumed the shipping would be too high for non-U.S. destinations. But as you've obviously already discovered, it's actually entirely reasonable. If you report positive findings I may just grab a couple myself.
@Alexsweden I suspect you're probably right as to the actual motivation for creating these glasses, but if they are decent for the task at hand I don't mind expanding my collection of glassware a little for the novelty of it and for variation's sake. Just like my mood will dictate which whisky I reach for, so does my mood dictate which glass I reach for.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Nelom It's interesting that they have an official bourbon glass now when they also have branded glencairns for sale...
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan I suppose they at the very least will want to unload existing stock before switching to the Libbey glass only, if they ever do.
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan can't find any dimensions for the glass or find any pictures that give it some relative scale. Were you able to get that information before ordering? If it's as big as the Glencairn Canadian I wouldn't be interested, but if it is about the size of a small snifter I would
7 years ago 0
I use Glencairns and Brandy glasses. The brandy glasses are 'fatter' at the bottom but the opening is a bit wider than the glencairn. To me this more resembles the brandy style glasses. It also looks like a chimney for a nuclear plant...
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@BlueNote
Only one way to find out.... When they arrive I'll photograph one side by side with a Glencairn...
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
In all cases, it shouldn't be worst than the Neat Glass, the one that looks like a spit bowl. That one was once the official glass of the San Francisco competition. So my guest is that with money any glass can become the official glass of somebody or something.
7 years ago 2Who liked this?
My go to glasses are standard wine tasting glasses (ISO or XL5) which I picked up from a 2nd hand shop for next to nothing. Stemmed, not too big, and a small aperture - and cheap to have a bunch for tastings with friends.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Hewie The glass you are using is what I called the INAO glass and I find it does a better job than a lot of whisky glasses. As I said before, the difference I notice with that kind of glass is that it enhances the highnotes and that it is why I still prefere the Glencairn.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
So here is the line-up so you can compare. From left to right mini, original, Canadian and bourbon glass.
I'd note that there is a pretty heavy (~25%) duty if you order them into Canada.
7 years ago 3Who liked this?
@Nozinan Looks nice. I was considering these, good to know about the added tax.
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan Thanks for posting that. I like that the base is wider than on the Glencairn. I suspected as much, but it's nice to have confirmation.
Have you had a chance to drink from it?
7 years ago 0
@Nelom It's interesting how different glasses change the experience.
I tend not to use the Canadian glass but given the shape of the lip of the glass I wonder if the liquid fall into the same part of the mouth as that one. It's noticeably different from the other glasses.
In terms of smelling, I found it seems to soften without muting the nose.
I must try bourbon in it soon.
7 years ago 0
WARNING
This is NOT a Glencairn. Glencairns are much better at keeping the liquor in the glass. If you forget what you're using when you bring this glass up for a sip, you may spill some of the contents.
I still prefer this glass for bourbons (is it psychological? Who knows?) but this does bear reminding...
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan I've ordered Glencairns from here and I've been happy with them. Have you ordered their "Canadian whisky glass" or their copitas? I was thinking of getting a copita or two for comparison tasting.
7 years ago 0
@OdysseusUnbound I have ordered from them in the past but I've found the least (or most)expensive way to get glencairns is at Spirit of Toronto. You get one with a ticket but then I think a box of 6 (and they had ones from different years so @paddockjudge and I could mix and match) was 20 dollars or something like that. With shipping I've found the ones at your link to be a bit pricy (but we have few choices). The cover glasses they sell are a little small (too small for Canadians) but they "bonnets" or "toques" are functional AND stylish. For function though, nothing bears a Pringles cover.
I have no copitas but maybe in the future.
I got a lot of Canadian glencairns at the LCBO.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
The bourbon glass looks like someone took the palm of their hand and pushed down on a molten Glencairn.
7 years ago 0
@BlueNote Yes it does.
I like it aesthetically and I like it in the hand.
I also find I enjoy bourbon in it. I recognize this could easily be "marketing" but I do like it.
7 years ago 0
I know there's been a number of glassware discussions here on Connosr, from the Glencairn(s), to the Neat glass, to the newfangled Norlan glass. Well, since there's an apparent appetite for glassware talk around here, I thought I'd fie up another discussion. This time about a glass claimed to be specifically for bourbon.
Here's an excerpt from an article I just read over at The Whiskey Wash:
A link to the full article with some quotes from the KDA and others: thewhiskeywash.com/whiskey-styles/bourbon/…
To my eyes the Libbey glass looks more or less like a Canadian Glencairn with a stubby stem. It's hard to tell what size it is, but the basic shape is very reminiscent. Since I like that glass, I can see giving these a shot if I were to ever come across one.