Bushmills Black Bush
A Pleasant Surprise
1 2984
Review by @OdysseusUnbound
- Nose20
- Taste22
- Finish21
- Balance21
- Overall84
Show rating data charts
Distribution of ratings for this:
This is an abbreviated version of a post that will be published on my blog tomorrow
I take jabs at Irish whiskey all the time, but I don't really worry about offending anyone, since, as far as I can tell, the Irish don't get offended. Or, at least not by a silly French-Canadian like me. Jocularity aside, I've always found Irish whiskey acceptable if somewhat dull and predictable, like action movies or romantic comedies. Irish whiskey is good in a pinch, I thought, but it doesn't merit the same reverence Scotch whisky commands. A good friend changed my mind somewhat with a tasting of Green Spot. While it's good, the price of Green Spot (here in Ontario) also buys a nice bottle of Old Pulteney 12, Glenfiddich 15, Laphroaig 10 or Highland Park 12. All of those suit me better than the Green Spot. But on a recent family trip, I purchased a bottle of Bushmills Black Bush and found an Irish whiskey that outperforms just about anything I've found at that price point (approx. $37 CAD).
Black Bush contains a "high proportion" of malt whiskey that was aged 8-10 years in Oloroso Sherry casks. What is "a high proportion" of malt whiskey? I don't know. I've read it's as high as 80% malt whiskey, but I can't seem to confirm this anywhere.
Tasting Notes
- Nose (undiluted): citrus (lemon), red fruit, red grapes, apples
- Palate (undiluted): medium-bodied, very little tongue-burn (bottled at 40% ABV), lots of red fruit (cherry, raspberry), malty, nutty, biscuits
- Finish: medium length, red fruit developing to milk chocolate, cinnamon with a licorice note lingering.
Adding water didn't change much in the character of this whiskey, but adding ice brought out more fruit and toned down a bit of the malt sweetness. I prefer this one neat, or maybe chilled. I would like to try chilling the bottle or even the glass. At 40% ABV, it doesn't need to be diluted any further, but tasting it cold was quite nice (heresy to some, I'm sure). I was surprised that the finish was as long as it was. I find Bushmills Original has a fairly short finish and I was surprised that this one went on as long as it did. Maybe the Oloroso casks had a prominent influence, or maybe it is close to 80% malt whiskey after all. I'm not quite sure where the longer finish comes from, but it's a treat.
Find where to buy Bushmills whisky
Yeah, short of switching over to bourbon, I'd agree that Black Bush is one of the best values you can find on the shelf.
I too would like to know where the long finish comes from. And not just on the Black Bush, but in general. Why do some whiskies have longer finishes? Sometimes people attribute it to long aging—especially in the negative sense, like Wow, that was a short finish for such an old whisky—but I personally have never noticed that correlation to begin with and I've never seen anyone articulate why older whiskies should have longer finishes.
As to the malt v. grain recipe here, I think a very underappreciated aspect to Bushmills' blends is that the Bushmills distillery only makes malt. All their blends are made with grain whisky they source from Midleton. I visited the distillery in 2014 and they did a good job dancing around that subject on the tour.