Whisky Connosr
Menu
Buy Whisky Online

Glenmorangie Companta Private Edition

SULPHUR

0 368

@MaltActivistReview by @MaltActivist

12th Apr 2015

0

Glenmorangie Companta Private Edition
  • Nose
    18
  • Taste
    18
  • Finish
    17
  • Balance
    15
  • Overall
    68

Show rating data charts

Distribution of ratings for this: brand user

Now let me tell you this. I first heard of sulphur in whiskies from Jim Murray a few years ago and he made such huge deal about it that I was literally looking over my shoulder to see when sulphur would attack.

But then as I kept tasting 'tainted' whiskies I couldn't really tell if they were truly sulphured or not. Jim certainly seemed to think so but I wasn't too sure. Then after doing some research I found out that you had to be genetically inclined to be sensitive to sulphur and more than a third of the worlds' population was not so.

I, therefore, assumed that I was one of the third and if I could not detect sulphur then so be it. In fact I was kind of glad. What spoilt whiskies for some would have no effect on me.

That is, until now.

After sitting for a month in an open bottle with no hint of anything sulphured (even though Jim in his 2015 Bible murdered this expression) I took it out to finally write this review.

This was an absolute disaster. What seemingly tasted decent when first opened had taken on the air of a spent canon. So strong was the sulphur that I barely had the chance to identify anything else.

OK, enough about the sulphur. Here is some info on what this whisky constitutes.

Vatting of standard 9 year-old ex-bourbon Glenmorangie finished for 5 years in red Grand Cru Burgundy wine casks from Clos de Tart (from Pinot Noir grapes), with a similar 10 year-old Glenmorangie finished for 8 years in a sweet fortified wine from Cotes du Rhone called Rasteau, made from Grenache grapes. The vatting contains 60% of the first, and 40% of the second.

My sample is from an open bottle and served at 46%

Nose: Underneath the flint, gunsmoke and spent matches there is some chocolate and red grapes. But that is all lost to the spectacular smell of a grand fireworks display.

Palate: I couldn't finish this dram. Something metallic coated my mouth and would not let go.

Finish: Metallic.

I am really shocked at how this whisky had turned after a month oxidizing. The sulphur, I guess, was always there and just needed a bit of air to bring it out.

At least now I know I am part of the two-thirds majority that can smell sulphur. And I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing.

Related Glenmorangie reviews

3 comments

@Victor
Victor commented

This review makes me eager to re-taste the bottle of Companta with which I am familiar. I reviewed it early after opening the bottle, and, like you, didn't notice sulphur at that point. Sometimes the sulphur is much more obvious after the bottle has taken some air.

9 years ago 0

@MaltActivist
MaltActivist commented

@Victor probably the best way to recreate the bottle would be to decant around 200ml and leave the rest to air. Try it a month later. That's what I did.

9 years ago 0

Taco commented

I've had three bottles of Companta with no issues. In fact they improved some with time, which extended over months. Maybe yours had some taint that "bloomed" with air exposure? Yours is a bit weird of a circumstance as any sulphurous nose or taste I've come across in a sherried whisky decreased with air time.

9 years ago 0