Discussions
66 19,381
Bruichladdich Port Charlotte Islay Barley 2008. It really opens up with a little water. I detect some of the same characteristics as the non-peated Bruichladdich Islay Barley Rockside Farm 2007 bottling.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
I had some Octomore 2.1 last night. I think it is magnificent. For peat lovers only.
7 years ago 2Who liked this?
@NamBeist, that is excellent to hear about the Octomore 2.1. I've never had a taste of it, but I do own an unopened bottle of it. That is one I have been saving to open for the future. So far I have never read anything but high praise for 2.1.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@Victor I have a 4.1 in the same condition. I did taste it at the store. It was fabulous. Wouldn't it be something to try those together?
7 years ago 0
Opened my Dissertation last night and I'm having more of it tonight. This is dram good stuff !!!
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@OdysseusUnbound It certainly is... I find it's a little weird on the first pour because of the shape of the bottle, but the whisky itself.... excellent!
7 years ago 0
Hi Everybody! Apologies for my extended absence. It's always nice knowing you are all here discussing important matters. Tonight I'm sipping one of my favorites, Aberfeldy! 12 year old to be exact. I had one bad bottle once and honestly, I swear no two bottles are exactly alike. Tonight's is a solid effort. Cheers!
7 years ago 2Who liked this?
@Wodha Great to see you back! May all your drams be outstanding!
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@OdysseusUnbound, have you tried hand-warming Dissertation in a brandy snifter?
7 years ago 0
@paddockjudge that picture makes me nervous. As a Science teacher I've seen even good quality laboratory glassware crack from a heat source concentrated in one area. It looks pretty cool, but I think I'll stick to the heating pads I was born with. On a side note, I accidentally broke my favourite glass last night by putting it down too firmly on the kitchen counter. Fortunately, I had finished my Bunnahabhain 12 by that stage.
7 years ago 2Who liked this?
@paddockjudge - that picture brings new meaning to "Sherry bomb". :-)
7 years ago 4Who liked this?
@Hewie, safety first! The tried and true method of hand-warming will stand the test of time.
7 years ago 0
@paddockjudge Nothing unsafe about the modified Ashok Manoeuvre, and it keeps your hands free...
7 years ago 0
I am enjoying a Springbank 12 CS, but I am still aware of the knock out by Octomore 2.1 . Yes, I am.
7 years ago 0
Toasting the sunset with some barrel strength bourbon with @Pierre ('scuse us while we kiss the sky).
7 years ago 7Who liked this?
@Nozinan, that would require me to buy an outdated computer with a fan....try leaving a flask full of whisky in the hot sun for an hour, the effect is incredible.
7 years ago 0
@Wodha, it is sad and sometimes embarrassing to encounter a bad bottle of a whisky which you have known to be very good. You may remember that I had a bad experience with the one bottle of Aberfeldy 12 which I purchased. It was a lot better 8 months later, though. I waited until it tasted much better before I wrote a review of it, then told the full story. A bottle redeemed by air exposure is much better than an unredeemable bottle.
The embarrassing part comes when you insist that your friend buy a bottle of something you have loved, they do, and then it turns out that what they bought tastes nothing like the wonderful stuff you have been used to drinking. That is a horrible experience.
7 years ago 0
@bwmccoy I just bought a bottle, but haven't cracked it yet. Love the 7.3 I have. What's your take?
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
@bwmccoy stunning view from the backyard jealous does not come into it.
7 years ago 0
@Nozinan and @Pete1969 - Thanks. We feel very blessed to live in such a beautiful setting.
@nooch - I love the 7.1. While it's not my favorite Octomore (nothing will ever beat Orpheus 4.1), 7.1 is very good! It is unexpectedly light and sweet (but not too sweet) with a huge explosion of flavor and complexity in the finish. I don't think you will be disappointed. I've never had the chance to try 7.3. Hopefully, I can still find a bottle.
7 years ago 0
@nooch - correction. Orpheus 2.2, not 4.1, is my all time favorite Octomore. Got them mixed up in my original reply.
7 years ago 1Who liked this?
Use the filters above to search this discussion.